Author's Final Manuscript
Gnosis: Journal of Gnostic Studies
This paper addresses responses to Drawing Down the Moon by Shannon Grimes, James Davila, Gregory Shaw, and Naomi Janowitz, using the cues of extraordinary efficacy, performance, social location, and ends to determine whether something is labeled magic and by whom. In each of the papers, the cue of social location appears as the most significant, even though the others each play a role as well.
Edmonds, R. G. 2022. “Who Does That?: Further Conversations on Drawing Down the Moon.” Gnosis: Journal of Gnostic Studies 7.1: 114–25.